How to Win Chargeback Disputes

How to Win Chargeback Disputes

Winning chargeback disputes is important for merchants because chargebacks take time to deal with and lead to financial losses and increased processing fees. Here’s a guide to help merchants navigate and win chargeback disputes in credit card processing.

What is a Chargeback?

A chargeback occurs when a cardholder disputes a transaction and requests a refund from their bank. The bank then initiates a chargeback, withdrawing the funds from the merchant’s account and crediting it back to the cardholder.

Credit cards have a strong value proposition of consumer protection. This is the main reasons chargeholders exists. Card holders can initiate a chargeback becuase of fraudulent charges, or becuase of dissatisfaction with the products from the merchant.

Common Reasons for Chargebacks

Chargebacks can stem from various issues. Here are some of the most frequent causes of chargebacks.

Fraudulent Transactions

  • Unauthorized Use: This occurs when a cardholder claims they did not authorize the transaction. It might involve stolen credit card information being used without the cardholder’s knowledge.
  • Friendly Fraud: Sometimes, the cardholder might make the purchase and then later claim it was unauthorized, either due to forgetfulness or an attempt to get the product or service for free.

Product/Service Not Received

  • Delivery Issues: The cardholder claims they never received the product or service they paid for. This can happen due to shipping errors, delivery delays, or miscommunication about delivery times.
  • Lost Packages: In some cases, the product might have been lost in transit, leading the customer to believe they never received it.

Product/Service Not as Described

  • Misleading Descriptions: The product received by the cardholder is significantly different from what was described at the point of sale. This could include differences in quality, color, size, or functionality.
  • Service Discrepancies: For services, the cardholder might feel that the service provided did not match the description or expectations set during the purchase.

Billing Errors

  • Incorrect Amounts: The cardholder was charged an incorrect amount, either higher or lower than what they agreed to pay.
  • Duplicate Charges: The cardholder’s account was charged multiple times for the same transaction.
  • Subscription Confusion: Recurring billing errors, such as being charged for a subscription the cardholder thought they had canceled.

Technical Issues

  • Expired Authorization: The authorization for the transaction expired before the transaction was completed, leading to a dispute.
  • Processing Errors: Errors during the transaction process, such as system glitches or incorrect entry of transaction details, can lead to chargebacks.

Miscommunication and Customer Disputes

  • Unrecognized Transactions: The cardholder does not recognize the transaction due to an unclear or unfamiliar merchant descriptor on their statement.
  • Poor Customer Service: If a customer attempts to resolve an issue with the merchant and is unsatisfied with the response or support, they may resort to filing a chargeback.

Canceled Orders

  • Failure to Cancel: The cardholder cancels an order, but the merchant processes the charge regardless.
  • Refund Delays: The cardholder might initiate a chargeback if they requested a refund and did not receive it within a reasonable time frame.

Steps to Win Chargeback Disputes

Winning chargeback disputes requires a systematic and well-organized approach. Here are the essential steps to increase your chances of success:

  1. Prevention is Key:

    • There are numerous things merchants can do to reduce chargebacks.
    • Clear Communication: Ensure product descriptions, terms, and policies are clear and accessible.
    • Prompt Delivery: Fulfill orders promptly and provide tracking information.
    • Customer Support: Offer excellent customer service to resolve issues before they escalate to chargebacks.
    • Transaction Receipts: Provide detailed receipts to customers.
    • Descriptor Clarity: Ensure your merchant descriptor is easily recognizable by customers.
  2. Gathering Evidence:

    • Documentation: Collect all transaction records, receipts, delivery confirmations, and any correspondence with the customer.
    • Proof of Service/Product Delivery: For physical goods, provide tracking numbers and delivery confirmations. For digital goods, provide access logs or usage reports.
    • Communication Records: Include emails, messages, or any other communication with the customer.
    • Policies and Terms: Provide copies of your return, refund, and shipping policies.
  3. Responding to a Chargeback:

    • Timely Response: Respond promptly to the chargeback notice. Delayed responses can result in automatic loss of the dispute.
    • Detailed Rebuttal Letter: Write a clear and concise rebuttal letter addressing the reason for the chargeback and providing evidence to support your case.
    • Submit Evidence: Organize and submit all gathered evidence along with the rebuttal letter. Ensure the evidence is easy to understand and directly addresses the chargeback reason.
  4. Understanding Chargeback Codes:

    • Familiarize yourself with chargeback reason codes. Each credit card network (Visa, MasterCard, American Express, etc.) has its own set of codes. Understanding these codes helps tailor your response and evidence accordingly.

Best Practices for Specific Chargeback Reasons

Chargebacks are a complex and challenging aspect of running a business, but understanding the specific reasons behind them can help merchants develop targeted strategies to address and prevent them. 

Each chargeback reason requires a unique approach to effectively respond and win disputes. In this section, we will explore best practices tailored to common chargeback reasons, providing you with actionable steps to mitigate risks and increase your chances of success when disputes arise.

Whether dealing with claims of fraudulent transactions, non-receipt of products, or billing errors, these guidelines will help you navigate the chargeback process with confidence and precision.

Fraudulent Transactions

  • Proof of Delivery: Provide proof that the product was delivered to the cardholder’s address.
  • IP Address Verification: For online transactions, provide IP address information and geolocation data.
  • AVS and CVV Matching: Ensure Address Verification System (AVS) and Card Verification Value (CVV) checks are performed during the transaction.

Product/Service Not Received

  • Delivery Confirmation: Provide tracking numbers and delivery confirmations from the shipping company.
  • Service Logs: For services, provide logs or evidence of service completion.

Product/Service Not as Described

  • Detailed Product Descriptions: Ensure product descriptions are accurate and detailed.
  • Communication Records: Include any communication with the customer acknowledging the receipt and satisfaction of the product/service.

Billing Errors

  • Transaction Records: Provide detailed transaction records showing the billed amount matches the customer’s order.
  • Refunds Issued: If a refund was issued, provide documentation showing the refund transaction.

Get the best payment chargeback support with Clearly Payments

  • Lowest-cost processing in the industry
  • Fund transfers in less than one day
  • A full set of payment products to accept payment anytime, anywhere
  • World-class customer service

Latest articles you might like

What is Embedded Payments?

What is Embedded Payments?

Embedded payments is about integrating payment processing capabilities directly into software applications, websites, and services to provide a seamless and customizable user experience.  As a

Read More »